Monday, 29 July 2013

Dr.Malpani explains why surrogacy is not a good solution for repeated implantation failure

Failed implantation is one of the most frustrating outcomes of an IVF cycle.
Failed implantation is one of the most frustrating outcomes of an IVF cycle. For most patients, the actual IVF treatment itself usually goes well . The quality of the embryo is good, the transfer goes smoothly and the thickness of the endometrial lining is also fine. Many couples even start referring to their  embryos as their babies
 ( “ embies”) . Transferring the embryo to the uterus is the last stage of the IVF cycle. And when their embies fail to implant and don’t become babies, coping with this failure is emotionally taxing, because they have already started bonding with their embryos. 

When the cycle fails, all their hopes come crashing down, and patients have complaints and want answers. Most doctors label this as implantation failure , and order multiple tests in order to determine the reason. They also offer lots of suggestions regarding what can be done differently next time to better the odds.
Most patients understand the fact that there is a 50% success rate for a perfect IVF cycle. However , with repeated failures , they want to fall back to an alternative plan. Many would change the clinic, but in case the same story is repeated , they begin to believe that something is wrong with their uterus. They start to consider surrogacy as their sole option.
Dr.Malpani believes this reasoning is flawed , even though it seems quite logical . After all, women believe that if even after transferring the best quality embryos into their uterus , they experience failure, this proves that the embryo has been rejected by the uterus, which leaves surrogacy as their last resort. She logically concludes that a surrogate has proven her fertility, and if she transfers her perfect embryo into her perfect uterus , this would result in a pregnancy and give her the baby which she has always longed for.
The reason this thinking is flawed is that in most cases , even the best looking embryos might have genetic problems which remain unidentifiable , and result in a failed implantation. These very reasons make the process of human reproduction very inefficient, and possibly delay the process of having a baby even for fertile couples.
If a perfect looking uterus fails to sustain a perfect looking embryo, then 90% of the time the problem lies with the embryo rather than the uterus. The
field of medicine works on a very simple rule i.e. when you hear the sound of hoofs, you must think of horses rather than zebras – common things occur commonly !


This is why surrogacy might not be the best possible option for those who have gone through multiple failures in IVF cycles. It has been found that the majority of these women have a completely normal uterus , and can carry a pregnancy. Their chances of having a successful implantation are considerably higher if the transferred embryo is developed using donor eggs from a healthy young woman. Remember that uterus cannot reject embryos, no matter what their source is , since it is an immuno logically privileged site.
POSTED BY DR.MALPANI
 Articles:

No comments:

Post a Comment